Used Subaru Forester for Sale in Madison, WI
Listing

Green • 2.5L H4 Engine
#50 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B
- Fair Price - $380 Above Market
- Includes $810 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner

Red • 2.5L H4 Engine
#66 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B-
- $25 Price Drop
- Fair Price - $234 Below Market
- Includes $261 Premium Upgrades

White • 2.5L H4 Engine
#140 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D
- $120 Price Drop
- Includes $831 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner

Black • 2.5L H4 Engine
#169 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: F
- $1,004 Price Drop
- Motivation to Negotiate - Very High
- Dealer Rating - 4.4 stars
Gray • 2.5L H4 Engine
#58 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B-
- Fair Price - $575 Below Market
- Includes $932 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner
Black • 2.5L H4 Engine
#147 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D-
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Very Low Mileage
- Dealer Rating - 4.7 stars
Silver • 2.5L H4 Engine
#109 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: C
- $2,980 Price Drop
- Includes $932 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner
Gray • 2.0L H4 Engine
#86 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: C+
- Fair Price - $480 Below Market
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Below Average Mileage
Silver • 2.5L H4 Engine
#120 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: C-
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Very Low Mileage
- Dealer Rating - 4.6 stars
Black • 2.5L H4 Engine
#12 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B+
- Great Price - $1,856 Below Market
- Includes $907 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner
White • 2.5L H4 Engine
#60 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B-
- $200 Price Drop
- Fair Price - $526 Below Market
- CARFAX: One Owner
Brown • 2.5L H4 Engine
#25 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B+
- $800 Price Drop
- Great Price - $803 Below Market
- Includes $587 Premium Upgrades
Gray • 2.5L H4 Engine
#23 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B+
- $493 Price Drop
- Good Price - $939 Below Market
- Includes $932 Premium Upgrades
Green • 2.5L H4 Engine
#135 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D+
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Motivation to Negotiate - High
- Average Mileage
Silver • 2.5L H4 Engine
#19 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B+
- Good Price - $1,123 Below Market
- Includes $1,313 Premium Upgrades
- CARFAX: One Owner
Blue • 2.5L H4 Engine
#179 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: F
- $57 Price Drop
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Motivation to Negotiate - Increasing
Black • 2.5L H4 Engine
#56 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B-
- $200 Price Drop
- Good Price - $914 Below Market
- Includes $865 Premium Upgrades
Green • 2.5L H4 Engine
#130 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D+
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Motivation to Negotiate - Increasing
- Dealer Rating - 4.5 stars
Gray • 2.5L H4 Engine
#100 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: C+
- Fair Price - $530 Above Market
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Motivation to Negotiate - Very High
Green • 2.5L H4 Engine
#136 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D+
- $78 Price Drop
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Motivation to Negotiate - Increasing
Silver • 2.5L H4 Engine
#131 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: D+
- $1,005 Price Drop
- CARFAX: One Owner
- Average Mileage
White • 2.5L H4 Engine
#32 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B
- $400 Price Drop
- Good Price - $1,076 Below Market
- Includes $932 Premium Upgrades
Gray • 2.5L H4 Engine
#99 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: C+
- Fair Price - $517 Above Market
- Includes $932 Premium Upgrades
- Motivation to Negotiate - Very High
Silver • 2.5L H4 Engine
#76 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: B-
- $300 Price Drop
- Fair Price - $247 Above Market
- Includes $1,103 Premium Upgrades
Brown • 2.5L H4 Engine
#172 Subaru Forester
CoPilot AI Buy Grade: F
- Below Average Mileage
- Dealer Rating - 4.5 stars
2026 Subaru Forester
Subaru Forester
Overview: Is the Subaru Forester a Good Compact SUV?
Combining car-like handling with SUV versatility and standard all-wheel drive, the popular Subaru Forester has delivered well-rounded capabilities for almost three decades. Sold as a two-row crossover, the family-friendly Forester employs boxer four-cylinder engines routed through Subaru’s acclaimed full-time AWD system across all trim lines. Strong resale values and competency on and off the road make the Forester a practical choice—no wonder they’re everywhere. The Forester is sold alongside the Impreza, Crosstrek, Outback, Solterra, Ascent, Legacy, WRX, and BRZ while competing against the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V, Mazda CX-5, and other compact crossover SUV models.
Arriving in the U.S. for the 1998 model year, the Forester quickly rose to become one of Subaru’s most popular vehicles. This overview covers more recent examples:
- Subaru Forester 3rd Generation: 2009–2013
- Subaru Forester 4th Generation: 2014–2018
- Subaru Forester 5th Generation: 2019–2024
Note: Equipment, features, and trims can vary by model year. Always confirm these details when looking for used Subaru Forester cars for sale.
Find a used Subaru Forester near me.
Related: Subaru Forester Pros and Cons: What To Know When Weighing Your Decision
Key Features
The Subaru Forester offers:
- Five-door compact crossover body style
- Naturally aspirated or turbocharged four-cylinder boxer engines (varying by year)
- Lineartronic continuously variable transmission (CVT)
- Symmetrical all-wheel drive (AWD)
Trims
Older Subaru Foresters were offered in X, LL Bean, X Limited, XT, and XT Limited trims. Eventually, the company shifted to a more familiar lineup: a base edition plus the Premium, Limited, and Touring Sport grades. The mid-tier Subaru Forester Sport was added along the way, and the Touring became the top offering. For 2022, the Subaru Forester Wilderness joined the range as a more rugged edition.
Comfort, Technology & Cargo
The Forester offers comfortable accommodations in both rows, although the middle spot in the back seat can be a tight squeeze for five people on board. Otherwise, there’s generous legroom and space for child car seats. Available luxuries like heated rear seats, a power tailgate, a Harman Kardon audio system, a moonroof, and the latest STARLINK touchscreen infotainment keep the Forester relevant. A tall cabin helps the Forester maximize its cargo space.
How It Drives
While older Foresters were available with punchier turbocharged engines, more recent examples are focused on efficiency. This approach is reinforced by a CVT that’s programmed for better MPGs. The Forester can handle its own during highway merging, but it's not a performance machine. The standard AWD system inspires confidence, especially during inclement weather.
Safety
The third-generation Subaru Forester gets a commendable four-star (out of five) overall safety rating from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). However, later editions received five-star rankings in the same testing.
Reviews
Owner reviews on Kelley Blue Book are quite favorable for the Subaru Forester. The ratings among the third through fifth generations range from 4.2 to 4.5 out of 5.0, with consumers praising the car’s reliability and value as top qualities.
Learn More: Here Are The Subaru Forester Years To Avoid and How Long Do Subaru Foresters Last? The Scoop on Vehicle Lifespan
FAQs
Is the Forester reliable?
While the Forester enjoys a generally good reputation for reliability, there are some trouble spots. In particular, carcomplaints.com cites the 2014 and 2015 model years as being known for engine-related problems. Some years, like 2017, have had above-average issues with the CVT. In addition, older Foresters (1999-2010) are infamous for bad head gaskets.
What are Forester weaknesses?
An aging interior design, lack of a third-row seat option, mediocre base audio system, and numb steering feedback on specific models draw rare complaints among owners and reviewers. Underwhelming engine power is another shortcoming.
Which is bigger, the Outback or the Forester?
The midsize Outback wagon significantly outsizes the compact Forester in terms of maximum rear seat legroom and overall cargo capacity thanks to its larger footprint and stretched wheelbase.
Why is the Forester popular?
Combining ample cargo room, strong safety ratings, and standard all-wheel drive traction makes the versatile compact Subaru Forester a top choice for young families or outdoor adventure seekers.


















