All posts

The FTC says a listed price should be the price everyone sees. New car shopping has never worked that way.

There's a debate happening right now about whether companies should be allowed to offer different people different prices.

A few weeks ago, the FTC proposed an enforcement policy on so-called "personalized pricing" — in other words, retailers using your personal data to decide what to charge you. The idea is simple: When consumers see a listed price, they expect it to be the same price that everyone else sees.

The New York Times just ran an opinion piece from the former chief technologist of the FTC, who made a version of the same argument, that companies shouldn't be setting prices based on personal information of individual customers.

I read both of those and thought: For most of retail, this is a new problem. When you're shopping for a new car, it's the oldest one there is.

All too often, the advertised price is not real

At CoPilot, we talk a lot about bait-and-switch pricing and the fees that dealers add on top of advertised price. These are the paperwork fees, "mandatory" extended warranty packages, and undisclosed, pre-installed products that turn $30,000 into $33,400 by the time you're in the finance office.

Personalized pricing is a related problem. It also pushes the number up, not because something additional was tacked on, but because the advertised price was never available to you to begin with.

Here's how it happens in the car buying process: Manufacturers offer incentives that come with conditions. There's money for recent college graduates. For active-duty military and veterans. Loyalty cash if you already own the brand. A bonus for financing through the manufacturer's own lender.

Dealers automatically apply all of them to discount the advertised price, even though almost no one would qualify for every single one. Some of them are even mutually exclusive by design; for instance, very few people are both a recent graduate and a fifteen-year owner of the brand.

The disclosure is usually buried somewhere on the page, in small print, or a few clicks away — something like "includes all available incentives; not all buyers will qualify." That's accurate. But this is what the FTC specifically said was illegal: The advertised price cannot take into account discounts that do not apply to all buyers.

You can't tell any of this from the listing. But you can find out before that number anchors everything that follows.

What to ask, before anything else

If you're in the market for a new car, here's what you should email or text the dealer before going in:

Before you go in

"Please send me the full, itemized out-the-door price, in writing, including all fees and add-ons."

Getting it in writing matters, because it gives you something to point to later if the number moves. Once you have this number, you can analyze it against the advertised price yourself, or upload the sheet to DealershipTricks and CoPilot will do it for you.

CoPilot can help

The gap between an advertised price and the real one is what CoPilot is designed to help consumers uncover and close. Upload the price sheet as soon as the dealer hands it to you, and we'll compare what's in front of you against what was advertised, flag any fees that shouldn't be there, and give you the language to push back with. Download our app here.

Know the real price

See what the advertised price is hiding.

Download CoPilot

Follow along at DealershipTricks as we continue to dig into what's really happening at dealerships across the country.