All posts

Breaking down bait-and-switch pricing: the common hidden fees we see and what to do about each one.

You find a car online for $25,000. You drive to the dealership, sit down in the finance office — and suddenly the number on the paperwork becomes $28,400.

It's not that the numbers don't add up. There's a line item for everything. But there are seven of them, half have names you've never heard, and the finance manager is explaining them at a speed that makes questions feel rude.

At CoPilot, I hear about this every day from our customers. Here's a rundown of the fees you're likely to run into, what each one actually is, and what to say when they show up.

How common is bait-and-switch pricing?

In June, we published an analysis of nearly 500 recent car sales from across the country, comparing what was advertised online to what buyers actually paid.

88%
of those transactions included fees added on top of the advertised price, averaging $1,055.
More than
1 in 4
had over $1,500 in fees.

Once you're at the dealership, these are the ones to look out for.

The fees, grouped by whether you can do anything about them

Group 1: Actually required by law. Pay these.

Sales tax, title fee, registration and plates, and state inspection are all fees you may see on your final bill. These are required by law, but the important thing to know is your state average for each. As long as you're being charged the correct amount, you can't negotiate them – but dealers will sometimes bundle 2-3 of them into one confusing line item, which makes it harder to tell if you're being overcharged. So it's worth knowing what each fee should cost on its own.

Group 2: The paperwork fee. Legal, but it must be in the advertised price.

The dealer will likely call this a "doc fee." It covers the dealer's cost of processing your transaction, and it's by far the most common charge we found — it appeared in 94% of the sales we analyzed, adding an average of $520.

The important part is a paperwork fee is not automatically a problem. Failing to disclose it upfront is. This spring, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sent warning letters to the auto industry about exactly these issues. They made it clear that advertising one price, and then adding non-tax or governmental fees later on, is not permitted under federal law. So if a paperwork fee isn't listed explicitly and built into the online price, and it turns up for the first time on the out-the-door sheet or in the finance office, that's an issue.

A dealer price sheet showing an undisclosed documentation fee

Group 3: Add-ons. This is where the money is.

Every one of these is optional, negotiable, or removable — even when it's already printed on the sheet we analyzed. The percentages and averages below come from the same ~500 transactions in our analysis.

What the dealer calls it What it actually is How often Average
Electronic filing fee, e-filing fee A second charge for submitting the same paperwork online — something already covered by the paperwork fee 17% of sales $175
Protection package, paint protection, ceramic coating, surface shield, appearance package Upcharges for products and services you didn't ask for 15% of sales $1,000
Security fee, LoJack, Karr alarm Anti-theft products pre-installed across the whole lot, billed as a line item — sometimes with a recurring monthly fee 10% of sales $664
Door edge guards, VIN etching, mudguards, floor mats, nitrogen fill, window tint Other items already physically on the car, then billed separately 5% of sales $479
Extended warranty, service contract, powertrain, CPO certification An optional service contract presented as required, often available through third parties for far less 5% of sales $1,480
Reconditioning fee, dealer prep, finishing touch Charging you to clean and repair the car before selling it — should be part of the dealer's cost of doing business 4% of sales $1,300
A dealer price sheet with add-on fees tacked on Another dealer price sheet with add-on fees tacked on

The out-the-door price is the only number that matters

The out-the-door price is the first and most important thing to ask for, not the monthly payment, not the sticker price, not the "internet price." It's an industry term, but all it means is the all-in price — an itemized breakdown of the total dollar amount you will pay to drive away. This request is probably the single most important one in your interaction with the dealer, because it will help you identify and push back on the fees we described above.

An itemized out-the-door price breakdown

What to say to the dealer

At the dealership

"Can you show me the full out-the-door price in writing, itemized, including all fees?"

When a fee appears that wasn't in the advertised price

"This fee was not in the price advertised on your website. Under federal law the advertised price has to include all non-government fees, so please remove this fee."

If they say an add-on can't be removed

And if the dealer won't budge, talk to the manager or owner. If they still won't budge, that tells you everything you need to know. Walk. There's always another car and another dealer that will treat you fairly. If you really want to you can always report them to the FTC.

You don't have to do this on your own

The CoPilot app pulls back the curtain on the dealership playbook and is by your side at every step.

How you'll use it:

Before you go in: Tell us the car you're interested in, and we can confirm it's available before you go to the dealer. And let us know if you have a trade-in – we'll give you competing cash offers to take to the dealership.

At the dealership: Upload the price sheet, the dealer's trade-in offer, and any financing documents as you receive them.

Using this info, we'll tell you whether the dealership is breaking the law. If they are, we'll give you everything you need to push back on them, from evidence to word tracks to even more. If you have a trade-in, we'll show you how the dealer's offer stacks up against your other offers, so you know you're not being lowballed. And if the finance office tries to sneak in any warranties or add-ons, we'll tell you what's overpriced or unnecessary.

Know every number

Catch hidden fees before you sign.

Download CoPilot

Follow along at DealershipTricks as we continue to dig into what's really happening at dealerships across the country.