Car dealers claim deceptive pricing is a fringe problem. Our data say otherwise.
When the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) warned the auto industry in March that deceptive pricing practices are illegal, my first reaction was relief — that this problem was finally being called out publicly.
I've spent the past two decades of my career in the industry, with nearly half of that spent building the software that dealers use to manage transactions. I've seen the dealer playbook firsthand: how they control information, wear customers down, and push them into decisions they wouldn't make if they weren't already exhausted by the process. This has never been a secret in the industry. It's an intentional strategy.
My relief quickly turned to frustration when I saw the dealer industry's response. Rather than acknowledge the problem, the National Automobile Dealers Association immediately issued a statement saying the "overwhelming majority" of dealers are compliant. In doing so, they essentially told the millions of Americans who have felt confused and taken advantage of in the dealership finance office: You're imagining this, it barely happens. As someone who has seen exactly how "bait-and-switch pricing" gets baked into dealership operations, that response wasn't just misleading; it was insulting.
So we went back to our data to see what it actually shows. At CoPilot, we hear about this problem every day from our customers — but we wanted to get a real grasp on just how false the dealer lobby's claims were.
"Bait-and-switch pricing" is exactly what it sounds like: a dealer advertises one price online, then adds fees at the point of sale that were never disclosed upfront, so the number you agree to and the number you actually pay are two very different things.
The "paperwork fee" is actually a good example of how this works. Dealers call it a "doc fee" — short for documentation fee — to make it sound official and unavoidable. What it actually is: a charge for completing the paperwork that's required to sell you the car. It's not optional for the dealer. It's not an extra service for you. It's a fee for something that was always going to happen — and it's dressed up to look like it belongs as a separate line item on your bill.
That's the playbook: Dealers name these charges on purpose to sound essential, when in reality, they're extraneous. "Extended warranties" get presented as a purchase requirement — they're not, and you can often find them through third parties at a fraction of the price. "Reconditioning fees" charge you for cleaning and preparing the car for sale, something that's normally already accounted for in the cost of the car. "Anti-theft products" get pre-installed on the car and then show up as a surprise line item in the finance office, sometimes with a recurring monthly fee attached.
These charges almost always arrive late in the process, after you've already spent hours at the dealership, when it feels like you've invested too much time and energy to simply walk away. The cost of these add-ons is not insignificant; according to our data, they average $1,055 per car. These aren't rounding errors. For most families, that's real money.
I'm a mom. When I'm making a major purchase for my family, I need to be able to trust the number I see. Most people do. What our data shows is that for the majority of car buyers, that trust is being violated — not by a small group of bad actors, but regularly, across the market.
The industry isn't going to fix this on its own. But at CoPilot, we're going to keep tracking it, publishing what we find, and building tools that put consumers on equal footing. We're committed to ending bait-and-switch pricing, for good.
