Your trade-in could be worth more than you think. Here's how dealers claw it back.
$13,330 — that's how much the average trade-in is worth above what people still owe on it, per new Edmunds data. That's real money you could be putting toward your next car.
That's also nearly double what it was before the pandemic. Most owners have no idea their car could be worth that much – and unfortunately, that makes it easy for a dealer to lowball the appraisal and pocket the difference.
Here's what typically happens. The dealer's appraisal comes back thousands below what you expected, and they give you any number of reasons: a chip in the windshield, "the market's soft right now," a service record they didn't like. Maybe some of that is legitimate, but none of it fully explains why the offer keeps landing thousands below where your own research put it.
Who this is actually happening to
It's not just luxury buyers or cash buyers sitting on that equity. This also applies to many regular owners of mainstream cars — Toyota Camrys, Honda CR-Vs, Ford F-150s — who financed normally and just kept their car running. The dealer can easily take advantage of the gap: If you don't know your number going in, you have no way to know when the offer in front of you is low.
Before you go: know your number
Look up your trade-in's value from more than one source before you ever set foot on the lot. Better still, get real, competing cash offers instead of just estimates: A cash offer holds up in a negotiation in a way a valuation-tool number doesn't, since it's a number another dealer is actually willing to pay, not just a guess. (This is something CoPilot can help with — more on that below.)
At the dealership: ask them to share the number separately
Ask for the trade-in offer in writing, separate from the rest of the deal. Dealers sometimes fold your trade-in value into the overall numbers, so it's harder to tell what you're actually being offered for your car versus what you're paying for the new one.
Use your competing offers to your advantage
Once you have a competing offer, bring it to the dealer and ask them to match it. It's important that this is an actual offer from another dealer in your area. Showing the dealer what a local competitor is willing to pay for your car gives them an apples-to-apples comparison – a KBB or Edmunds valuation will feel less real to them and won't carry as much weight. It's true that getting an actual competing offer takes more effort than pulling up an online estimate, but it's worth it. It's the one number a dealer can't wave away easily.
Why this works: Trade-ins are the cheapest way for a dealer to get inventory. The alternative is buying at auction, where they're competing with other dealers and usually paying more. A trade-in offer in hand is real leverage you can use.
CoPilot can help
Before you ever go to the dealership, the CoPilot app can get you competing cash offers for your trade-in from other dealers, so you have a real number to compare against, not just a guess. Then, once you're at the dealership, upload the dealer's trade-in offer and we'll show you exactly how it stacks up against those competing offers, so you know whether you're being lowballed before you sign anything.
